General Words:
E-books are a part of the wider
electronic milieu and as such they have been seen as providing special benefits
in the classroom. There are several reasons why they are seen as beneficial,
including the increase in academic achievement and the decrease in the cost of
student textbooks. E-books have generally been seen as improving learning
outcomes. They can help students to learn more effectively and teachers to
become more efficient in their teaching.
E-texts in the classroom:
As new technologies are
attractive to many students, using e-books can
also be motivating. Various features of e-books can provide support for
students with print or reading disabilities. Some e-book programs have
interactive dictionaries, providing justin-time learning, by allowing users to
select a word in the e-book and get an instant definition. They can also have
the definition read aloud, or request an instant translation to another
language. Features such as these can increase students’ attention and
comprehension. A number of researchers have looked at the influence of new
technologies on student achievement. However, they are not uniformly positive
about their role in academic achievement. One example is a study done by Sheppard,
Grace and Koch in 2008. They examined the perceptions and performance of nearly
400 students taking an introductory psychology course. They found that the form
of the textbook (electronic or paper) did not have any influence on students’
grades. They said that students using the e-textbooks reported spending less
time on course-related reading but nevertheless evaluated the electronic text unfavorably.
No student who purchased an electronic text in a prior class chose to purchase
one for the introductory psychology course. The authors suggest that it may be
premature to abandon paper texts in favour of electronic ones. Some researchers argue that it is not the
technology itself, but how it is applied. Harold Wenglinsky in his study, Does
it Compute:
The Relationship between Educational Technology and Student
Achievement in Mathematics, found that not all uses of technology were benefi
cial. He argues that using software to create simulations had a positive effect
on academic achievement, while using computers to teach low-order thinking skills
was counter-productive. Clark and Mayer also say that it’s not delivery
mediums, but instructional methods that facilitate learning. Their 2003 study
shows that when the instructional methods remain
essentially the same, so does the learning, no matter how the instruction is
delivered. However, a number of studies
have found that technology does have a positive role in academic achievement.
The United States Department of Education conducted a meta-survey of studies
that contrasted online and face-to-face learning, from 1996 to July 2008. The
meta-study confirmed that higher education students in online learning courses
generally performed better than those in face-to-face courses. Charlotte Johnson and William Harroff argue
that e-books can be part of the solution to the illiteracy problem.
They point
out thatrather than focusing solely on
digitising print text and worrying about redefi ning the term book, publishers
of electronic materials should take full advantage of the multimodal learning
styles that can be addressed by well-designed electronic publications. The cost
of student textbooks is a further concern, and authors such as Charles Hannon
say that electronic formats will reduce textbook pricing. The amount of money
students have to spend on textbooks is signifi cant. In the United States, for
example, students spend up to $1,000 per year on textbooks. A study conducted
in 2006 by the United States National Association of College Stores has shown
that nearly 60 per cent of students choose not to buy all the course materials.
In 2008, the Northwest Missouri State University undertook a study on the
feasibility of transitioning from the renting of traditional textbooks to
renting e-textbooks. The study involved four faculty members (selection was
based mostly on the availability of appropriate e-textbooks for courses).
E-textbooks were provided to laptops from several different publisher
platforms, including Vital Source and CourseSmart. The survey showed that cost
considerations were an important factor in student decision-making with respect
to electronic versus print textbooks. Other
fiendings of this study were that students have a high affinity for
handheld electronic devices but that enthusiasm for e-readers quickly wanes in
the absence of the desired search and annotation features. Both students and
faculty considered keyword searching and annotating as very important features.
Students think of e-readers as attentiongetters but not attention-keepers.
Students also liked the idea of not having to carry heavy textbooks in their
backpacks. The considerations about carrying books have also been raised on the
popular blog TechCrunch, where Michael Arrington wrote that carrying print
books is ‘as big a pain as it has been for past generations of students’ and
that ‘a new large screen Kindle would solve those problems’. In 2009 Princeton
University participated in the Amazon Kindle DX pilot program. The majority of
students and teachers said they were not pleased with the Kindle’s slow
performance and limited features and that the Kindle limits interaction with
the text.
The campus newspaper, The Daily
Princetonian, published the following comments:
Much of my learning comes from a
physical interaction with the text: bookmarks, highlights, page-tearing, sticky
notes and other marks representing the importance of certain passages – not to
mention margin notes, where most of my paper ideas come from and interaction
with the material occurs. All these things have been lost, and if not lost
they’re too slow to keep up with my thinking, and the “features” have been
rendered useless. The adoption of e-textbooks is obviously a very complex
process, and involves many factors. Kenneth Sherman and Ethel Vesper in their
2009 article, Monetize Hidden Value in eBooks and Other Digital Learning
Assets, did a meta-study of 14 articles on the applications and benefi ts of
electronic textbooks.
The authors conclude that ‘transitioning to digital
materials impacts not only students, faculty and administrators, but also
curriculum development, instructional design, customer service, technical
support, academic services and purchasing’. They also say that, to ensure
digital transition is completed smoothly, the e-book adoption has to be aligned
with the course development process fl ows and procedures. In the context of
e-textbooks, there has been an interesting initiative by Macmillan, one of the
fi ve largest publishers of trade books and textbooks. Macmillan has launched a
new software package called Dynamic Books. This enables lecturers to customize
e-textbooks for their individual classes. Instructors can alter particular
sentences and paragraphs without consulting the original authors or publisher,
and also upload course syllabuses, notes, videos, pictures and graphs. Because
these textbooks are going to be so modifi able, the New York Times has called it
a kind of ‘Wikipedia of textbooks’. The
research literature indicates that, although student and faculty experiences
with e-books have been various, they have been mostly positive. As digital
technologies continue to transform the environment for teaching, learning and
research, we will continue to see new developments with e-books as well.
No comments:
Post a Comment